KANSAS CITY, Mo. — U.S. corn and soybean yield projections fell below market expectations in the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s crop production report Nov. 10.
Arlan Suderman, StoneX chief commodities economist, peeled back the USDA numbers following the release of the bullish report that temporarily pushed up commodity prices before the market fell back two days later.
Corn yield was reduced by 1.6 bushels to a U.S. average of 179.6 bushels per acre. The average trade estimate leading up to the report was 180.3. Was that a surprise to you?
Suderman: Our customer survey came in at 183.1. I know a lot of people criticized us for that, but that’s what our customers told us. That was our official estimate. My yield model, which got a lot of criticism a year ago July, was precisely at 179.6. That’s the final yield number for the yield model. So, it’s been performing very well for me, and it gave me that indication that was a possibility.
I think the trade was braced for the possibility USDA may have a higher yield, but generally the trade was expecting something to come down, and it came down a little bit more than what was anticipated by the trade.
Does corn yield continue to get lower? How rare is it to have yield go down in corn from October to the November report?
Suderman: Historically, if you look back since 1993, about 60% of the time when they went up in October, they went up again in November. So, this went against that longer-term trend.
If you look back over the last 10 or 20 years, it was maybe a little bit the other way. So, it was not really a surprise from that standpoint, but at the same time, it did break the longer-term historical tendency to come down.
I think there’s a lot of farmers out there who are probably saying, yeah, this is what they needed to do.
Do you think the corn yield will be smaller going forward?
Suderman: The trade’s going to assume that any adjustments in January will be small. Of course, the last couple of years, we’ve seen some surprise big adjustments in January. I think the USDA is trying not to have a repeat of that this year. I think there will be a fraction of a yield change. I’m not expecting a market-moving change in corn yield in January.
Illinois corn yields were down 8 bushels an acre from last month, Nebraska was 4 bushels lower, Minnesota was up 9 bushels from October, and Iowa was unchanged at a record 219 bushels per acre, up 8 bushels from the previous record. So, what do you make of that November corn yield estimates shift across the Midwest compared to the previous month?
Suderman: There were five states with record corn yields, down from what we saw in October, with records in Iowa and Minnesota and great crops in Indiana and Ohio, as well.
We had some states that really did well. We had some states that really disappointed. This was a combination of those numbers and probably a fair assessment of the crop.
Corn ending stocks are now estimated at 1.758 billion bushels, down 91 million bushels from last month’s supply and demand estimates. That put stocks-to-use at 10.8%. The pre-report trade average guess was 1.84 billion bushels. Does this now effectively bottom the market?
Suderman: Not necessarily. That is an adequate supply to meet anticipated demand as we go forward. So, there’s no reason to ration demand with higher prices at this point. The real risk is we’re about 300 million bushels behind the seasonal pace that we need to be on to hit USDA’s export target. So, there is a risk that we see that export target come down. That’s a risk the market has to respect.
The focus now is going to be on Brazil and how El Niño affects their growing season for their winter corn crop, which won’t even be planted until February. We’re going to be watching the long-term weather forecast to see if that might be a risk or not.
If it’s not, then corn probably has downside risk. If it looks like it’s going to be, then those risks for the higher prices start to come back again.
But for corn, the bigger story probably is going to be the fact that both corn and soybeans need to see added acres next year. The assumption is that corn is going to lose some acres in the coming year, and if that’s the case, then we for sure have to have a record yield next year.
The market hates to assume that weather’s going to be perfect in the coming growing season, and we for sure need to see a yield increase for soybeans next year.
For corn, the story is probably the acreage battle next year. That leaves us vulnerable over the next six months between now and then.
USDA increased the U.S. average soybean yield by 0.2 bushels from last month to 53.3 bushels per acre. The pre-report average trade estimate was 53.5 bushels per acre. Many expected the yield to be even higher. Was the market already trading for a higher yield?
Suderman: I think the whisper number, the way the market reacted, is probably a yield of 54.5 to 55 bushels per acre. USDA comes out with a 53.3. They give us ending stocks of 300 million bushels. But the export number could go up at least another 100 million bushels if China goes ahead and follows through on the 25 million tons that we think. That means we’re still tight. That means we still have some more rationing to do.
On the other side of that, Brazil is watching their crop conditions and they’re saying they’re going to have a big crop. That’s the way it’s looking right now anyway. That could change in December.
Brazil is seeing China buy U.S. soybeans, and every bushel of U.S. soybeans they buy is one less bushel China’s going to buy from Brazil. So, they’re saying we need to sell rallies.
We may not go lower, but, at the same time, going up is going to be more challenging going forward, because we’re going to see Brazilian farmers selling into the rally, and that’s going to slow the progression upward.
Do you anticipate soybean yields going up from here?
Suderman: That’s a real possibility. As we approach that January report, which is the next time we’ll get an adjustment in supply, I think the market’s going to be braced for the possibility of a more significant increase in soybeans.
They’re probably feeling pretty comfortable with the corn yield, but for soybeans, I think there’s going to be a nervousness ahead of that January report.
:quality(70):focal(275x269:285x279)/cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/shawmedia/PNJLQGHDNVFALHCLIATOFNH3OM.jpg)
:quality(70)/s3.amazonaws.com/arc-authors/shawmedia/ed197490-54d0-4d57-8027-b878c9f46789.jpg)